Thursday, June 11, 2009

Post 3: Varying Immigration Experiences

America was commonly known as the land of opportunity, or sometimes simply, the land of better wages.  Though many different people came here for different reasons, with different motivations, and in fact experienced life differently after their settlement.  

For instance, Jewish immigrants came because they were commonly denoted as the "other" group of people back in their home land.  They were commonly a persecuted ethnic minority, and usually felt that they were not able to return to their homeland.    They lived in what was called the "Pale of the Settlement,"  a region that bordered the culture with boundaries with forces just beyond.    Their towns were dangerous, and violence was common in the form of pogroms, large bloody massacres.   

What brought their travels to America were hopes of freedom, and opportunity.  Children and families were among the newcomers, often residing in New York's lower east side.  But this place called home  was different than what they were used to.  New York was a fast paced place to live, "an American atmosphere of breakneck speed and breathless enterprise."    Their newly placed Shtetl in America was "packed" with people, as they were living in the same home with tens of others. Their trades in the city brought entrepreneurial spirit, commonly involving their sewing skills.  Others, took part in working at sweatshops, where work was "physically punishing."

Jewish immigrants were commonly kept from entering schools, such as Harvard, and were rarely promoted to the white collar job market.   Though, Jewish people commonly embraced the US possibilities and strived to assimilate and to become American.

Mexican migrators had a different story.   While they also saw America as the land of opportunity, they knew they hadn't do much to get their.   Passing the border was easy for many, and roads into the country were usually flooded with people moving for a better life.  

But was life really better?  The "Estados Unidos" was a land of wealth and prosperity,  and after all, the Mexicans were leaving a life driven by unfair land owners deemed as "robbers" and even dangers of violence after the Mexican Revolution.   Still, people had hopes to come to America and still be Mexican, not to assimilate to the American culture. 

Mexicans were commonly kept from many types of work in the US.   In our readings, one man describes how he could never be a carpenter.   In fact, Mexicans claimed only 5% of managerial occupations in the US while Anglos held nearly 30% in 1920.     Women also worked in steel packing houses, garment factories, and even automobile assembly plants, but most help positions in agriculture.   Land owners here believed they could take advantage of the Mexicans, one saying "The Mexican cannot be driven like he Negro, but anyone who knows how to manage them can get more work out of them than any other class."   

Strikes were common among Mexican workers, as the previously described attitude was a usual for bosses and managers.  Segregation was not only commonly in the workplace, but also throughout  life.   Mornings for students would begin as they traversed off into their Mexican only schools, in their Mexican towns within their "Mexican borders," (the barrio) very similiar to the way that they lived in Mexico.  But it is important to know that these people did not want to assimilate and to become American.  They desired to keep their own cultures and to keep their own community.   Mexican holidays were also continuing to be practiced, such as Mexican Independence Day.   Overall, these people were looked down upon by Anglos, and were commonly segregated from the varying US peoples.  

7 comments:

  1. I also found it interesting that the Mexican people had no real intention of assimilating to American culture. They were only here to take advantage of the prosperous economic condition.

    Even more interesting is that it was so easy for them to move back and forth across the border. They could literally live a Mexican life and then drive over the border to work. I find it really surprising to live a life in that type of scenario where you are constantly shifting from one culture to another.

    When considering your post it is almost as if the Mexican and Jewish people were complete opposites. One comes and goes as they please; another has no hope of returning. One wants to become "Americanized", another has no intention of that ever happening. The list goes on and on...yet they all share a common goal in forging a better life and I find that fascinating.

    ReplyDelete
  2. The land of higher wages? Just how low were the wages elsewhere? Anyway, the immigrants had a choice, either be assimilated by American society or live on the fringes of it. Sort of like the situation in Star Trek involving the Borg. "Resistance is futile."

    ReplyDelete
  3. From the readings we have completed in this class I have gathered that higher wages in the United States were a major factor in the decisions of many people to immigrate here. I may be wrong but I think that the low wages in America were still higher in most cases than in their home country. Once they were in America they saw that they were being payed below the "American standard" of the majority. This lead to the formation of labor unions and strikes to gain fair and equal wages.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree the wages in America are way higher. To immigrants eyes it was like gold. They would be able to make more moeny, so they can provide for their families better. The Americans tried to scare them off, but in the end it didn't work and both groups are doing better now then they would be in their home country.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Right. I would have to say that wages in the US were likely still higher than in their native country. Problems in the US were caused by long hours and non-established labor laws, but notice this is why many workers unionized and fought for change. Could they have done this in their home country? Probably not. In the end, the US was probably still a place more favorable than their native lands, but getting to this point was not easy.

    ReplyDelete
  6. That is so true David, in their home countires, no matter what ethnicity, many could probably not fought for and won the rights that they had. The higher wage, less working hours, and better conditions mayhave neer truely come. Although they did have to deal with the racism and assimilation, they did deal with this well and probably benefit and are stronger because of this. Also, without their strikes and fighting, who knows what working conditions would be like today.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I believe it is understandable to why Mexicans didnt want to assimilate to the american culture. Why would you want to culturize to the group of people who tries thier hardest to dehumanize you? If somebody was constantly abusing your people and treating you unfairly with unfair wages and a low quality school system, would you want to become apart of that culture? I can understand why these groups of people did not want to assimilate to american culture and i find it brave as well for them to stay in a place where they felt unwelcomed. Does the want for better overwhelms humans more than the want for respect? Is it better that we endure racial pain and live better financially, rather than be treated as equals but have insufficient financial life?

    ReplyDelete